To answer the main question you've asked: Will Google Wave reinvent the way we communicate digitally or fall flat?
I think it's still too early to tell, but I think that there is a spectrum there, in terms of whether it fully reinvents online communication or falls flat. It may very well end up displacing some online communication platforms, but may not end up becoming a ubiquitous standard. Despite its ambitious goal, Google has definitely shaken things up a bit, and in my opinion has already changed the way we think about communicating with each other online.
Because Google Wave is actually a
product (browser app), a
platform (open APIs)
, and an open source network protocol, I think the "elevator" pitch depends on your audience. See
Google Wave in a Nutshell.
Most people equate Google Wave with the product, which is still in its early stages. One thing to keep in mind is that Google Wave is a cutting edge HTML 5 app, and it is pushing the envelope in terms of what can be done in the browser. The app itself will improve no doubt, and it will become more widely supported as browsers catch up with the HTML 5 standard and browser performance improves.
I think as we've seen with Twitter, an ecosystem of applications and complementary services will emerge based on the Google Wave APIs and the network protocol (which by the way is based on XMPP).
Breaking down the features and benefits of Google Wave boil down to changing a user's perspective to view online communication as the creation of a 'document' in Google Wave. Conversations in a wave have
no other equivalent, yet they share the same qualities as email, IM, wiki, and online documents. I remember when people didn't 'get' microblogging, and now it seems like a de facto part of online communication for many out there. So I think there's potential there.
The video posted on the other answer is pretty good at condensing the original Google Wave intro video. Of course, you could refer to my
Introduction to Google Wave article as well. :-)